
Confessions of an over-breather
I had no idea how much of an over-breather I was (and still can be!) when I began my Alexander Technique training. Nose breathing was recommended sometimes, but I didn’t understand it’s relationship to sense receptivity at the time.
Over-breathing just means too much inhale, and not enough exhale.
This builds up CO2 in your system, basically, and you can feel dizzy, pressured and stressed. When teachers guided me to pay attention to my breathing, all I knew was that I felt worse.
I felt somehow overstuffed, tight, and stressed. There was something that always happened when I focused on breathing, but for the life of me I didn’t know what it was. Nowadays folks call it “air hunger” but that phrase wouldn’t have made sense to me at the time.
I didn’t feel hungry. I felt stuffed!
I knew breathing was supposed to be easier, but following the instructions for something like the Alexander Technique practice called “whispered ah” did not really help me find ease.
This is “The Whispered Ah,” taught on most AT training courses:
- Breath normally, in and out through your nose, with your lips gently closed
- Think of something funny and smile gently behind your eyes.
- On your next exhale, say a whispered ah as you breath out through your mouth without tightening your tongue (it should rest on your lower teeth) or neck. You are opening your lips and jaw, not tipping your head back.
- Gently breath in through your nose again without pulling your tongue, face, or head into your neck; exhale the whispered ah sound without pushing or squeezing.
- Repeat two or three times, then let your breathing take care of itself and “reset” autonomically.
I pretended I understood this procedure, but truthfully, I did not.
Not for years. Yes, I was nose breathing, but my body refused to believe that I could lengthen my exhale without taking a deep…deep….DEEP breath in first.
The idea is to “get out of the way” of your breathing, which will result in a lengthening exhale. This is in alignment with the work of Carl Stough, who discovered that one could in fact help people with emphysema recover strength in their diaphragms through gently, slowly increasing the length of an exhale.
It had been previously thought this wasn’t possible, so it was a lifesaving miracle for the people that were lucky enough to work with Carl. He went on to inspire Jessica Wolf, who combined Carl’s work (Breathing Coordination) with the Alexander Technique.
Jessica Wolf (her wonderful work is called The Art of Breathing) would say that us AT folk had slowly forgotten our roots in breathing and voice.
Breathing was a main concern of FM Alexander in his earliest teachings and throughout his career.
So why couldn’t I get it? Well, to give myself credit, I was patient. I didn’t worry about it, and trusted that it would sort itself out. It was clear I couldn’t think my way out of my problem.
After teaching for 7 years, I thought I was ready to face the breathing again. I signed up for Jessica’s Art of Breathing training eagerly. It was amazing. I made some progress.
It turned out, however, that my progress on the course was not as valuable as a surprise return of my old breathing patterns at the closing ceremony.
There were about 15 of us in a circle. We were sharing what we had learned. I had something absolutely brilliant to say, and raised my hand.
But Jessica did not call on me. There wasn’t time. And I had to sit there breathing, with my lips closed. Why did I want to take a deep breath and hold it? It was somehow connected to the desire to talk… while feeling somehow not heard. Fuck it. Take a big breath in, and bloviate anyway, was my old habit!
This is the moment of opportunity. Can I see a deeply ingrained habit without acting on it, judging myself, or trying to fix it either?
Because of the training I was able to stay in myself, with myself, without taking that big breath. A huge wave of emotion came over me around an old, familiar experience of not being able to speak, being cut off, not being heard, that had no cause in the present moment.
I saw clearly that when I spoke, I never let myself pause, or fully exhale. I was afraid that if I paused for a new, quiet breath to come in, I would never be allowed to speak again. Instead, I’d not finish my exhale, quickly breath in again and keep talking, lest someone cut me off.
Waves of anger and frustration washed over me.
Wow. Sitting with those feelings and that memory was such a gift. And not having to breathe like that even so. Letting the feelings, like the breathings, come and go.
Later on, I learned to wait one whole breath cycle after someone finishes their sentence before I speak.
Often, if I do that, I discover they haven’t finished their thought yet!
All of this came back to me as I was recording my scientifically based, poetically embodied video about nose breathing this morning.
Maybe nose breathing is an easier way in (for me, at least) because it taps into your phylogenetically oldest sense organ; your olfactory system.
Our eqautic ancestors once had a vomeronasal organ, which sensed heavier chemical molecules in the water. Many land animals, like horses, cats, and dogs, still have one. Primates still have the organ but it’s vestigial, no longer innervated.
Once we became land creatures, a second olfactory system evolved in response to the lighter and more varied chemical molecules in the atmosphere which were essential to our survival.
This is what the olfactory nerve looks like:

Below is the image I share in the video of the beautiful patterns created by the olfactory nerve endings in a mouse nose. Each curve and spiral indicates a different type of cell that evolved to sense a particular chemical in our atmosphere.
While we have only 500 different types of chemoreceptive neurons, mice have 1100.

I’m so grateful that my ability to be receptive has been restored.